Riddle me that

Meaning

Used to pose a challenging question or highlight a contradiction in someone else's argument. It frames the situation as a curious puzzle.

Skeptical, dramatic

Used in a sentence

• If you say you were busy but I saw you at the park, riddle me that.
• He claims to love quiet time but owns three drum sets, so riddle me that.
• How can we be out of money when we just got paid, riddle me that?